Following President Trump's return to office, Democrats are reportedly reassessing their approach to opposing his administration. A recent Politico report highlights the internal struggle within the party to regain public trust after their electoral defeat. Several Democratic strategists and officials expressed the need for a shift in tactics, moving away from the “resistance” approach that characterized Trump’s first term.

One key concern is President Biden’s low approval ratings and voter dissatisfaction with issues like inflation, cultural debates, and border security. A former staffer for Vice President Harris emphasized the need to “earn people’s trust back” by changing their approach. The constant media presence of party leaders like Nancy Pelosi and Chuck Schumer during the previous administration is now being questioned, with some advocating for a more measured response.

An advisor to a potential 2028 presidential candidate suggested that Democrats should focus on substantive policy critiques rather than relying on “endless resistance headlines.” This sentiment was echoed by Michigan state Sen. Mallory McMorrow, who advised a more direct yet less strident approach to criticizing the administration.

The Politico report also pointed to a leadership vacuum within the Democratic Party, presenting both challenges and opportunities for aspiring leaders. Some see this as a chance to redefine how the party addresses working-class concerns and challenges the perceived “ruling elites,” though this may require a shift in rhetoric. However, other strategists caution against overreacting to the recent defeat, warning against excessive caution that could hinder effective opposition.

The report suggests a tension between the desire to present a strong opposition and the fear of repeating past mistakes. Some worry that the intense focus on resistance during Trump’s first term may have ultimately hindered Democratic candidates in subsequent elections. The party now grapples with finding the right balance between holding the administration accountable and charting a path forward to regain public support.